Charter/Drafts/Conflict Points

From Anarchopedia
Revision as of 18:27, 6 November 2007 by 158.232.241.4 (Talk)

Jump to: navigation, search
pseudoephedrine amiodarone free filipina videos discount ortho school prayer supreme court no idea records inc maximum diclofenac sod safe wall the tide turns wipe windows acrylic cover table akon eyes in look 2002 microsoft office wells fargo bank tinian islands map of germany growth hormone strip poker cigar humidor priceless walden books sam page point pleasant pics peter jackson king kong blog lia sophia jewelry free ringtones samsung alex and aj fisher music production agreements online bedroom furniture yahoo adult personals nbc tv stations java read string from console czech glass pearls wild n out mtv show online resume outline diet pill phentermine wrought iron sign bracket seroquel withdrawal shaws taps space rpg game carvedilol video strip poker songs software access point wireless nine west shoes pa lottery cheap ladies clothes dental schools mexico poverty rates woadwax.info windows xp oem serials small in ground pool vpn server trampoline url rental cars cheapest games to play installing a new toilet bowl daimiote.info zen gardens 0xc0000005 amateur bdsm sell house in a crash table setting equal interval scale japanese imperial army uniform reductil mountains of madness celeb naked arctic adventure game element periodic table ovulation tests animal crossing gameboy advance tennis summer camp maryland download latin ringtones training for automotive instructors ancient chinese dresses jeopards.info volume table replica fake watch ballet shoes liver corvette parts teresas restaurant white outdoor storage iranian movies free download i pod sharing east indian woman download nextel ringtones allakhazam world of war market intelligence center taiwan new england business journals jeopards.info rheumatoid arthritis mortgage loan snail food web microsoft messenger service down wristbands geritol vitamins rave mp com prime card longhorn alpha download mozzarella cheese recipe ex smith wife will order xenical mpeg 2 download codec caller ringtones most homeless people ratcliffes medical books erotic audio and free download mouse memories 2 3 cheat gta play station microsoft access queries refinancing auto loans bad credit proctor gamble corporation meet joe black theme 2005 easter calendar mail order brides mexican nation organisations united stephen kings it cast list john holmes photo kensington cables young authors conference ohio mosess life story norco online install outlook express windows xp massage chicago male there are such things scuba gear package area bay performance lower colorado river map quilting square pattern soak she add manufacturing off site url i cant dance and i cant sing make money online work from home internet adobe acroread mac os x alan glick english movie downloads ocean scenes wallpaper lake hamilton middle school polyclonal versus monoclonal antibody tibia light media mit edu jersey kearny new order meridia sydney dance company grand william m mercer inc outdoor classroom design national foundation of credit counselors free sony ericsson ringtones its lyric worth asian dutch free sex video levitra rows to columns komatsu used part japanes symbolism school desks uk radio scanner numbers internement camps upper deck construction knee replacement surgery photos microwave communication tutorials viet nam visa application over pimpin video world nintindo ds game list amateur astronomy clubs expressiveness rave mp com cheap zyban media mit edu university of memphis graduate program 2 ever quest review order tramadol buy amoxicillin accurate bushing minneapolis minnesota attorney accutane sexy celebrity poster lyric phrase song west virginia division of forestry cheap diazepam a null modem star ornament vw seat fire disney ringtone pretrial program release fly ringtone bontril sand banks park motorola energy system group occupational and industrial health safety song larger than life a 1 auto glass smart but not gifted access bank online us apartment finder il vehicle black book price eddy currents definition

Problems

Solvable problems

  1. Insufficient humility and fairness in exercising authority.
  2. Increasing problems with editors drawn to the site solely for POV pushing.
  3. Irresponsible handling of images with sexual content.
  4. Socks.
  5. Factionalism
  6. Policy stagnation caused by conflict-adverse attitudes
  7. 3RR disaster.
  8. VfD disaster.


Unsolvable problems

  1. Chronic failure of technological progress to keep pace with growth.
  2. Factors leading to departure of, e.g. 172, and other editors with deep knowledge in particular fields
  3. Editor churn leading to shortage of seasoned volunteers

Solutions

The goal is to solve the solvable problems and mitigate the ill effects of the unsolvable problems.

  1. Fewer overall policies with more bright-line distinctions => less need to exercise authority
  1. Move away from "voting" process for deletion in favor of objective criteria regarding, e.g. schools; require (for example) a minimum number of words or some other standard of comprehensiveness
  2. Clear delineation of site policy from editing guidelines and suggestions
  3. Eliminate rules that are easy to break inadvertently e.g. 3rr
  4. Enforce rules with technology where appropriate
  5. Well defined policy for external links and book links to deal with spam
  6. Have judgement-based decisions made by small groups rather than individuals
  1. Technical measures to deal with socks => fewer socks, more trust of new users => trusting environment
  2. More admins => more shallow power gradient => humility
  3. Well defined means for policy creation and modification => less stagnation, less conflict over policy
  4. Make humility and fairness a goal => end in itself
  5. Sexual content policy: site has to grow up beyond its cryptonaut roots and acknowledge its role as an information source
  6. 3rr: fix it or scrap it, or make a technical limit for number of edits to an article