Orcs

From Anarchopedia
Revision as of 20:16, 10 July 2007 by 203.162.27.90 (Talk)

Jump to: navigation, search

free punk ringtones free funny ringtones free cool ringtones free funny ringtones didrex online paxil online lorazepam online mtv ringtones alprazolam online cheap pharmacy online sony ringtones free ringtones vigrx online free polyphonic ringtones free mp3 ringtones free polyphonic ringtones polyphonic ringtones tramadol online cheap adipex but ultracet cheap viagra buy diazepam zoloft online cheap vigrx cheap lisinopril cheap pharmacy online cheap celexa free sprint ringtones clonazepam online levitra but sildenafil order vicodin xanax online cheap valium pharmacy online online cheap sildenafil cheap wellbutrin adipex online vicodin online free wwe ringtones free alltel ringtones free verizon ringtones midi ringtones buy prozac cheap lipitor sony ericsson ringtones free sony ringtones cheap albuterol cheap viagra carisoprodol online sony ericsson ringtones propecia online nexium cheap lorazepam flexeril online free tracfone ringtones cheap clomid paxil online motorola ringtones cheap zyban free qwest ringtones free nextel ringtones clonazepam online free music ringtones tramadol online cheap soma cyclobenzaprine online tramadol online buy ativan adipex online nexium online cheap clonazepam hgh online cheap tenuate online zoloft free midi ringtones order alprazolam cheap ambien free sony ericsson ringtones cheap lisinopril free midi ringtones cheap carisoprodol free nokia ringtones funny ringtones cheap didrex buy hgh didrex online free sony ringtones ultram online buy hgh ericsson ringtones fioricet cialis online order flexeril carisoprodol online real ringtones hoodia online but ambien lipitor online free online pharmacy free ringtones zanaflex online phentermine online diethylpropion online buy soma free sprint ringtones diazepam online sharp ringtones cheap hydrocodone adipex xanax online cheap clomid tracfone ringtones free sharp ringtones online lisinopril cheap wellbutrin kyocera ringtones free motorola ringtones cheap phentermine buy zoloft carisoprodol online alprazolam online cheap diethylpropion nokia ringtones cheap albuterol funny ringtones valium online buy tramadol fioricet online cheap viagra free samsung ringtones mtv ringtones order norco free music ringtones ativan online tenuate online buy lipitor free ericsson ringtones order soma ambien online rivotril online online cialis buy tramadol ericsson ringtones mtv ringtones cheap propecia jazz ringtones kyocera ringtones cheap viagra but norco alltel ringtones buy zanaflex motorola ringtones viagra online cheap lortab music ringtones mp3 ringtones buy albuterol buy clonazepam cheap ambien xenical online free real ringtones cheap nexium online wellbutrin free sonyericsson ringtones celexa online cheap diazepam free nextel ringtones cheap soma mp3 ringtones online hoodia nextel ringtones cheap vicodin free sagem ringtones punk ringtones propecia online free mono ringtones free polyphonic ringtones levitra online wwe ringtones lorazepam online free samsung ringtones buy zanaflex online norco buy nexium cheap ultram buy hoodia hgh online cool ringtones mono ringtones rivotril online buy meridia cheap cialis free jazz ringtones clomid online ortho cheap ativan diazepam online cingular ringtones cheap valium English Wikipedia User Xiong coined the Tolkienesque term "orc" to describe a somewhat trollish user with unusual qualities of cleverness, persistence, and flexibility.

Orcs may or may not oppose trolls; they do not troll as intensely as a common troll. An orc masquerades as a genuine user, and may even make an occasional substantial contribution. An orc may fight a troll, or even another orc, hoping to steal the mantle of a knight; but often merely plods along in a groupthink vein, playing to the crowd, gathering support by acting with the mob, and occasionally looking to see where the mob is going -- and getting there first. He hopes to build up a reserve of public trust based on his frequent appearances on the "right" side of battles against straw men. He may thus acquire cat's paws or sparewheels. This is the orc's "passive mode".

When the orc shifts gears into "active mode", he fastens upon some object -- usually another user, but perhaps a group of users or an abstract concept -- and attempts to eradicate him, them, or it. He is unusually persistent and flexible in his attacks. Unlike trolls who generally "ignore all rules" except the most clearly established (since "rules" are so easily manipulated by orcs themselves - see below), the orc treads the edge of the acceptable, attempting to drag his opponent to this unsafe battleground. A successful orc attack is completed when his victim, not the orc, finally crosses the line into sanctionable action (c.f. MeatBall:Sucker Punch and [1]). But absent this satisfaction, the orc persists until he exceeds community tolerance.

Another feature of the orc is his fascination with policy. He avoids substantive contribution and manipulates policy to his own ends. His flexibility is key. When stymied at one point, he goes to higher ground, looking for some policy that can be creatively twisted to support his vendetta. He fades in and out of active and passive modes, from direct attack to subversion of process. If he perceives a gray area, he pushes it as far as it will go; then he switches sides and pushes there, too, until nothing is left but a fine line between right and wrong.

The real danger of the orc is not that he destroys other users; users can be replaced. It is not that he vandalizes articles, policies, and tools; they can be rebuilt.

The orc, by playing constantly in the gray area between "okay" and "not okay", forces the community to resort ever more frequently to formal procedure, tribunal, and written, explicit policy. That might almost be a Good Thing, but a social group founded on more or less anarchic principles maintains its integrity via meatball:SoftSecurity, which depends on some shared self-image and a certain level of mutual trust. Orderly anarchy, as opposed to chaos, depends on members working to avoid testing limits and provoking contention. By forcing the group, bit by bit, to adopt strict methods to exclude bad actions, the orc destroys orderly anarchy and replaces it with a slapped-together mess of improvisation -- ad-hocracy at its worst - which is easily manipulated by other orcs.

Orcs have a symbiotic relationship with martinets, who strive to create an atmosphere of rules, obediance, and structure as an end in itself. Some manage to be both at once.

The Orc's destruction cannot be reverted. Once that mutual trust is destroyed, there is no way to regain it; once resort to authority replaces shared consensus, it becomes the first resort in all cases. This social glue is precious and fragile, and the orc erodes it by his every act.

Thus the orc is the most dangerous of all troublesome users.